ERT Information
ERT Jobs
Stay ahead of the competition
> Go
RSS Take a Town Feed

Take a Town

Take A Town is ERT’s popular mystery shopping feature, where each month our mystery shopping team calls in on 10 retailers in a town to put the stores – both independents and multiples – through their paces.

Through a set 10-point criteria, each store is appraised on a number of areas, including product knowledge and customer service.

Our mystery shoppers pose as normal customers and look to buy a product or service and monitor how the sales staff interacts with them.

Take A Town is not out to put people down, it aims to promote retailing excellence, but our mystery shopping team can only report back on what takes place on each individual visit. That said, it is worth pointing out that the mystery shopping team’s verdict of stores has to be taken at face value. The team visits each store only once, so it is the service that they get, on that one visit at that particular time, on that particular day that makes the write-up in Take A Town. Our industry has a great history of providing excellent customer service. Take A Town is part of ERT’s drive to raise store standards.

As a result, from January 2009, stores scoring over 7/10 in Take A Town will be automatically entered into the ERT Industry Awards, which will take place in the autumn.

Gloucester
05 November 2009

About town

 

• Gloucester is a city, district and county town of Gloucestershire and is 32 miles north-east of Bristol, 45 miles south-south-west of Birmingham.

• Gloucester was founded in AD48 by the Romans as Glevum, and was granted its first charter in 1155 by King Henry II.

• The city is the 53rd largest settlement in the UK by population. In 2001, it had a population of 123,205. However, according to the 2001 Census, the Gloucester urban area had a population of 136,203.

• Gloucester has a long history in the aerospace business. In 1926, the Gloucestershire Aircraft Company at Brockworth changed its name to the Gloster Aircraft Company because international customers claimed that the name Gloucestershire was too difficult to spell.

• In July 2007, Gloucester was hit badly by a flood that struck Gloucestershire and its surrounding areas. Hundreds of homes were flooded, around 40,000 people were without power for 24 hours, and the entire city and surrounding areas were without mains water for up to 14 days.

• The Three Choirs Festival, originating in the 18th century and one of the oldest music festivals in Europe, is held in Gloucester every third year, the other venues being Hereford and Worcester. Gloucester is due to host the festival in 2010.


Go with the MotionFlow
HAVING just started to subscribe to Sky+ HD, I was keen to get a bigger TV to enjoy the high-definition content, so I headed to the Sony Centre on Eastgate Street.
Outside the store, I spotted a sign that was advertising a TV trade-in offer. Inside the store, Rich said: “Basically, we’ll take any TV, any make, any model, any size, whether it’s working or not, and we’ll give you money off a new TV.
“The amount we give you depends on what size TV you are interested in buying. If you buy a 26in to 37in, we’ll give you £50; if you go for a 40in, you’ll get £100; if you go for 46in or above, you’ll get £150.
I said a 40in set would be ideal.
Rich asked what devices I currently had connected to the TV and I said Sky+ HD, a DVD player and a Nintendo Wii console.
He then asked me whether I watched sport on TV and I confirmed that I did, when I get the chance.
Rich said: “The reason I ask that is because if you like sport, or documentaries with panning scenes, if you’re budget allows it would be best to go with the Z Series, because it’s got the 200Hz MotionFlow technology.”
He presented the KDL-40Z5500, which was on sale at £1,399.99.
He talked the through DLNA connectivity, explaining that this would give easy wireless access to video, music and photos stored on compatible devices elsewhere in the home.
I told him that I liked the TV and Rich offered me the chance to buy the TV on 12 month’s interest-free credit, for a 10 per cent deposit.
He pointed out that the TV came with a five-year warranty, but he recommended that I consider taking out accidental damage cover, which he said would cost around £100 a year.
“It’s a useful thing to have, particularly as you’ve got a Wii,” Rich said.
Before I left the store, Rich demonstrated Sony’s MotionFlow technology by showing me the same moving image on 50Hz, 100Hz and 200Hz sets.
Score: 10 out of 10

Greet but not so good
AFTER reading about the UK’s first Blu-ray recorder in ERT recently, I headed to the Comet store on the St Oswalds Retail Park to find out more.
I entered the store and was immediately greeted by Martin. I then made my way to the Bluray area of the store and was surprised to see that a Panasonic TV, connected to one of the Bluray recorders, was switched off.
The TV, a 32in set (TXL32G10B), priced at £699, and the Blu- ray recorder (DMRBS750), also £699, were part of a display area dedicated to the new Blu-ray products.
I counted five members of staff serving customers, while six other members of staff were wandering idly around the store.
As I continued to browse, I also noticed another of the new Blu-ray recorders from Panasonic. This more highly specified model (DMRBS850) was on sale at £999.99.
According to some point-ofsale, using a Blu-ray recorder, consumers can “record from multi sources in high definition” and save recordings “in HD on Blu-ray discs”.
After more than five minutes’ browsing, and with no signs of any approach, I walked out.
Summary: My visit to Comet started promisingly with a greeting from Martin, for which I have awarded one point. Sadly, that was as good as it got. After finding the product I was interested in, I was ignored by the six members of staff who were wandering around the store, seemingly without a care in the world.
Score: 1 out of 10

Gaz helps put baby in the picture
WITH my baby due any time, I headed to Sight 2 Sound on Northgate Street to look at camcorders to capture my new arrival’s first few years.
Gaz was adjusting the window display, while another member of staff was unpacking a delivery.
After a couple of minutes, Gaz joined me and I explained what I was looking for.
Gaz asked if I wanted to look at a high-definition model and I said that would be ideal.
He first presented a Sony model (HDR-CX105E), which was on sale at £448.99. Gaz said the model had an 8GB internal memory, which could hold around three hours of HD content, but he said that the quality could be reduced to get more recording time. He also said the memory could be expanded if I bought a Memory Stick Duo.
He handed me the Sony model and I said how light it was.
Gaz then handed me a Panasonic model (HDC-TM10), which was on sale at £488.99. He said the Panasonic model also had an 8GB memory, but it had a slightly longer zoom and it had a SD card for expanding its recording time.
I asked Gaz if he would recommend one of the products over the other. “I don’t think you’d be disappointed with either, to be quite honest,” he said, although he did point out that SD cards were a little cheaper than Memory Stick Duos.
Gaz mentioned briefly the new Panasonic Blu-ray recorders. He said that by connecting the camcorders to the recorder, I could record HD content on to Blu-ray discs. “That’s the first on the market to do that,” he said.
I asked Gaz for some information on the models he had presented and he gave me copies of brochures from Sony and Panasonic.
I thanked him for his help.
Summary: Gaz was friendly and helpful and his product knowledge was good. I have knocked off two points as he did not demonstrate either of the products or attempt to close the sale.
Score: 8 out of 10

Rich is ready for HD
AFTER moving into my new flat just outside Gloucester, I wanted to get my hands on Sky+ HD, so headed for the Currys Digital store on Eastgate Street.
I went to the rear of the store and was greeted by Rich as I made my way to the Sky display. I picked up a Sky leaflet and was soon joined by Rich, who explained: “There are three different options. There’s normal Sky, Sky+ and Sky+ HD.”
He asked whether I had an HDready TV and I confirmed that I did.
Rich began his sales pitch by talking me through the channel package options.
He explained that I would need to choose between one and six ‘mixes’.
Packages, he said, started at £17.50 a month for one mix, or I could have all six mixes for £22.50 a month.
“Once you’ve chosen which package you want to go for, you then choose if you want any premium channel, like movies or sports,” he said.
“If you want everything, it’ll cost £47.50 a month all in; with the high-definition costing an extra £9.75 per month for all 33 of the high-definition channels. Virgin and Freesat only have two HD channels.”
I asked Rich how much it would cost for me to get a Sky+ HD box and have a satellite dish installed.
He asked me if I had a home telephone line and once I had confirmed that, he said it would cost £29 to get it up and running.
He highlighted how good a deal he had offered me by saying that an installation would normally have cost £60 and that the Sky+ HD box was £300 when it first launched.
Rich then demonstrated the Sky+ HD interface and he described the Sky+ functionality as “the best thing since sliced bread”.
He showed me how to record a show and then how to review something that had already been recorded. He demonstrated live pause and rewind, too. He also mentioned that it was possible to set a programme to record when I was not at home by using my mobile phone.
I asked how quickly I could have Sky installed and Rich said it could be done within a week.
I thanked him for his help.
Summary: Rich offered a good level of product knowledge and was able to demonstrate Sky+ HD well. I have, however, deducted one point as he did not close the sale.
Score: 9 out of 10

A little short on details
I WAS in desperate need of a new washing machine, so I headed to Gillmans on St Oswalds Road.
After eventually managing to park my car, as the store’s car park was heaving, I went inside.
I threaded my way past workmen’s ladders on my way to the washing machine area. After two minutes, a gentleman asked if I needed any help.
The man asked me if I had a specific make, spin speed and load capacity in mind. I told him that my current machine was a 1,400 spin, 5kg machine.
He asked if I was looking for a freestanding or built-in model and I said I was looking for a freestanding model.
He showed me a 6kg, 1,400 spin machine from Zanussi (ZWF14070W), which was on sale at £306. He said the machine was simple to operate, using the programme dial.
He then showed me a 6kg, 1,600 spin machine from Zanussi (ZWF16070W), which was priced at £324.
I asked how much it would cost to deliver the machine and the man asked if I lived in a GL postcode area. I said I did.
“If we arrange a delivery on a certain day, would you accept it at anytime during the day?” the man asked. I said that would be OK with me.
“There’ll be no charge then,” he said, “and for £5 we’ll take away your old machine.” I thanked him for his help.
Summary: The man was friendly, but I expected him to talk more about the products he presented. I left the store with two products in mind, but did not really know much about them to be honest.
Score: 4 out of 10

Gerry fails to focus on the sale
IN SEARCH of a digital SLR camera for my forthcoming trip, I headed for the London Camera Exchange on Southgate Street.
Gerry greeted me and I explained that this would be my first digital SLR. I asked what I should be looking for, and what he could recommend.
He told me that entry-level models start at around the £500 mark and he said that the new Nikon D3000 and the Canon 450D “are probably the two most popular entry-level ones”.
Lifting the Nikon box off the shelf, Gerry said the D3000 came with an 18-105mm lens and was priced at £599, while the Canon 450D was priced at £499.
I asked what the main differences were between the Nikon and Canon models.
“There’s not a lot of difference between them,” he said. Gerry led me outside the shop to show me another Canon model that was part of the window display. The 500D was priced at £599.
“The main differences between the two Canon models is that the 500D is a 15 megapixel camera, while the 450D has 12 megapixels,” he said.
Gerry also mentioned that the 500D has a movie mode, which turns the camera into a video camera.
“Movie mode is quite a new feature on digital SLRs,” Gerry said.
I asked for some information and Gerry gave me a copy of the Nikon D3000 brochure.
Just as I was about to leave, Ger r y ment ioned tha t the store was set to run a Canon promotional week later in the month, something it did every year.
He said: “On one of those days, there’ll be a chap from Canon here, demonstrating the cameras and showing them off to their full potential.
“It’ll probably be the last week or two of November – there’ll be lots of promotions on Canon.”
I thanked for him for his help.
Summary: Despite greeting me, giving me basic product details and talking about a promotional week, I felt disappointed that Gerry did not remove any cameras from the display cabinets and did not offer to demonstrate any of the products he had mentioned.
Score: 4 out of 10

‘Lush’ LG in the running
MY DAY in Gloucester continued with a visit to the Power Point store in Hucclecote.
I was on the lookout for a new washing machine. Inside the store, a woman greeted me and asked if I needed any help.
She asked me if I was looking for a particular make and I said that, for me, product reliability was the key purchasing factor.
The woman explained that all prices quoted in the store included the cost of delivery, installation and scrappage of the old appliance.
She said the store’s washing machines started with a 1,400 spin, 5kg machine from Beko (WM5140) at £250. She also highlighted products from Gorenje, Statesman and Zanussi.
I told her that I liked the look of an LG model (F1222TD). The 1,200 spin, 8kg machine was on sale at £370.
The woman described the LG model as being “lush” and she explained that the 8kg drum could cope with a double quilt.
I noticed that the machine was a Direct Drive model.
The lady explained that this made the machine very quiet compared with other machines on the market.
She wrote down product details for all the machines she had mentioned and I thanked her for her help.
Summary: The woman was friendly and offered basic product information. She was able to mention a few features of the LG machine, but I felt that she could have helped me more.
Score: 2 out of 10

Diane has something better to do
ONE THE Eastern Avenue Retail Park, I noticed a sign outside the Currys store that highlighted a 25 per cent discount on all Dyson vacuum cleaners.
Keen to find out more, I headed into the store. After a few moments, Diane joined me and asked if I needed any help.
I said that I was looking to buy a new vacuum cleaner and was keen to take advantage of any promotion.
Diane said that the 25 per cent offer was available to customers who trade in their old cleaner and would be reflected in the price of a new cleaner.
Diane asked me if I preferred a cylinder or upright cleaner and I said I thought a cylinder model would be best.
She showed me three Dyson cleaners – the DC23T2 (£187.99), the DC23 allergy (£209.99) and the DC22 Animal (£209.99).
After showing me the machines, Diane just walked off.
I decided to follow her example, and I walked off myself, right out of the store, rather gobsmacked, and disappointed.
Summary: Diane explained the trade-in offer, but was unable to give any detailed product information. After showing me the Dyson cylinder cleaners, she just walked off, which left me rather nonplussed.
Score: 1 out of 10

Not crema of the crop
AFTER seeing a coffee machine advertised in one of my wife’s glossy magazines, I went to the Debenhams store on Kings Square to see what was available.
I climbed the stairs to the homewares department on the second floor of the store and was promptly ignored by a member of staff.
I began to browse the products on display and was potentially interested in two machines – the Bosch Tassimo at £117 and the Krups Dolce Gusto, which was displayed on a freestanding pointof- sale stand, at £127.
After five minutes, a sales assistant walked towards me, before turning around and walking back in the direction she had come from.
Disappointed at being ignored, not once, but twice, I left the store.
Summary: In these difficult times for retail in the UK, stores can ill afford to ignore customers. Being ignored in stores is what I call ‘retail suicide’ and is a prime example of bad retail practice.
Score: 0 out of 10

No shot at getting served
WALKING along The Oxbode, I was drawn to a poster in the Jessops shop window advertising the launch of the new Canon Powershot G11.
According to the poster, the camera, on sale at £569, would come with a cashback offer of accessory vouchers worth up to £150.
Keen to find out more, I went into the shop, which was reasonably busy, with three members of staff serving customers and another two, plus myself, waiting to be served.
I looked in the display cabinets for the Powershot G11, but could not seem to find it.
After waiting to be served for more than five minutes, the queue of customers was getting longer and with no prospect of being served, I regrettably had to leave this busy store.
Summary: The store was very busy. All the staff were tied up serving customers, while others patiently browsed as they waited to be served. I was not able to get served myself, so I cannot give the store a score for my visit.
Score: 0 out of 10

Summary

MY TEAM enjoyed their day visiting Gloucester’s electrical retailers, although the weather in Gloucestershire could have been kinder.
They witnessed some excellent examples of product knowledge, sales skills and customer service.
While the majority of stores performed well, this time it was down to Comet, Currys, Jessops and Debenhams to really let the side down.
I know I am starting to sound like a broken record, but ignoring customers during a recession is retail suicide.
That said, there were so many great examples in Gloucester of what retailing should be about. Congratulations to Rich and Rich. this is not some new comedy double act, but the names of the sales assistants we met in the Sony Centre and Currys Digital.
The two members of my team who went to the Sony Centre and Currys Digital said that, based on their experience in your stores, they would have had no hesitation in purchasing from you, so well done. Demonstration is the key to sales and you guys embraced it. Good job.
I must also give a mention to Gaz at Sight 2 Sound, who did very well, too. This month’s plaudits go to Rich, Rich and Gaz.
As of September 2009, all those who score more than seven points will automatically be entered into the ERT Industry Awards for 2010.

Top of the Town

Independents Multiples

Winner:

Sony Centre

Winner:

Currys Digital

Commended:

Sight 2 Sound

 

 

PREMIER LEAGUE

  No. of visits Total points Average per call

B&O

2

20

10

Apple

3

25

8.3

Panasonic Stores

8

58

7.3

Sony Centres

21

145

6.9

Independents

63

401

6.4

Richer Sounds

10

49

4.9

Currys.Digital

19

75

3.9

Department Stores

21

65

3.1

Comet

20

56

2.8

Jessops

18

43

2.4

Currys

18

12

0.7

Marks & Spencer

1

0

0

Robert Dyas

1

0

0

PC World

4

0

0