ERT Information
ERT Jobs
Stay ahead of the competition
> Go
RSS Take a Town Feed

Take a Town

Take A Town is ERT’s popular mystery shopping feature, where each month our mystery shopping team calls in on 10 retailers in a town to put the stores – both independents and multiples – through their paces.

Through a set 10-point criteria, each store is appraised on a number of areas, including product knowledge and customer service.

Our mystery shoppers pose as normal customers and look to buy a product or service and monitor how the sales staff interacts with them.

Take A Town is not out to put people down, it aims to promote retailing excellence, but our mystery shopping team can only report back on what takes place on each individual visit. That said, it is worth pointing out that the mystery shopping team’s verdict of stores has to be taken at face value. The team visits each store only once, so it is the service that they get, on that one visit at that particular time, on that particular day that makes the write-up in Take A Town. Our industry has a great history of providing excellent customer service. Take A Town is part of ERT’s drive to raise store standards.

As a result, from January 2009, stores scoring over 7/10 in Take A Town will be automatically entered into the ERT Industry Awards, which will take place in the autumn.

Worthing
04 June 2009

About Town

  • Situated at the foot of the South Downs, Worthing, in West Sussex, is 60 miles south of London and 11 miles west of Brighton.
  • Worthing had a population of 99,600 at the time of the 2001 Census.
  • Within a radius of seven miles around Worthing’s town centre are four of Britain’s major Neolithic flint mines, out of only 14 confirmed flint mines in the whole of Britain.
  • Worthing is home to several major employers, including GlaxoSmithKline, HM Revenue and Customs, MGM Advantage and Southern Water.
  • Although perceived as prosperous and voted three years running the most profitable town in Britain, the 2004 annual earnings survey found that residents’ average pre-tax pay was only £413 a week, compared with £474 for the South East.

  • A DAB hand selling digital radio

    ON A mission to fi nd out more about digital radio, I headed to Roger Green Sound and Vision on Rowlands Road. I entered the store and was greeted by a smiling man, who was standing behind the counter.
    I explained that a friend had recommended digital radio to me and that I wanted to find out more.
    The man said: “Digital radios go from the £40 mark, for a little kitchen/bedside type of product, to bigger… hi-fis, really. Which room do you want to put the radio in?”
    I said I would like to have the radio in the kitchen, primarily, but if it was a portable product, I may use it in the bedroom, too.
    The man pointed out that, in and around Worthing, the digital signal was not great. “If it’s on a window-sill, that’s fine,” he added.
    He switched on the Pure Evoke 2S (£169·99), which he pointed out was connected to an external aerial. The radio began playing BBC Radio 3, but the man demonstrated the menu and selected BBC Radio 7. I said it looked very easy to operate.
    “You find what you want to listen to, press a button and you go to it,” the man said, “it’s so straightforward, it’s brilliant.”
    He demonstrated the product’s ReVu feature, pausing the radio for 10 seconds or so, and then restarted the broadcast. He said this feature was ideal for when you want to go and make a cup of tea.
    I asked how many stations I could pick up in the Worthing area. “It depends on the signal where you are, but somewhere between 20 and 30,” the man said.
    I asked for some information and he gave me the Pure brochure and the Roberts Radio’s digital collection brochure.
    Handing me the information, he said: “The next step up from digital radio, is internet radio – both Pure and Roberts do them.
    “If you’ve got a wireless router in your house, then buy one of these radios.” He pointed to the Pure Evoke Flow product on the front of the Pure brochure.
    “Basically, you select what country you want, or what style of music you want, and it comes up with a list,” he said.
    “If you’ve got music on your PC, it can play that. We’re yet to have it in stock to demonstrate, but we’re seeing how much interest there is in it. The Evoke Flow retails at £150.”
    I thanked the man for his help and said I would return.
    Summary: The man was very calm and collected, but demonstrated DAB and its key features. He had excellent product knowledge and I would have had no hesitation in purchasing from him.

    Score: 10 out of 10


    Full load of information but no closure

    WITH my retirement imminent, I thought I’d invest in a new washing machine and so headed to Lyles on Findon Road. As I entered the shop, two members of staff greeted me and I headed for the major domestic appliances area.
    After a few moments of browsing, one of the salesmen approached me and asked if I needed any help.
    I said I was looking to buy a new washing machine, but was honest and admitted that I didn’t really know what I was looking for.
    He presented a Hotpoint machine (WML540) – a 1,400 spin model. “It’s normally £329, but we’re doing it for £299 at the moment, which is quite a good price,” the man said.
    He pointed out that the model had variable spin speed and variable temperature settings and he mentioned that all Hotpoint models had an automatic half load feature.
    He said he was waiting for delivery of a Bosch model, which retails at around £399.
    “It has the same functions, but the only extra that the Bosch has is an LED panel that tells you how long it is until your wash finishes.”
    I asked for some information.
    “If you’re local,” the man said, “we don’t charge any extra for delivery or installation. We only charge £10 to dispose of your old one. We also offer next-day delivery.”
    I asked if the man could recommend any other options.
    “There are washer-dryers,” the man said.
    I asked whether they were expensive.
    “The Hotpoint (WDL520) is £399,” he said.
    He handed me a copy of the Hotpoint laundry brochure and marked the products he had presented.
    I thanked the man for his help.
    Summary: From my initial greeting from the two members of staff, I felt comfortable, as the salesman was friendly and knowledgeable. One point was knocked off, as he did not attempt to close the sale.

    Score: 9 out of 10


    Telly quest inconclusive

    IN THE hunt for a new TV, I drove to Churchers on Rugby Road. On entering the store, I was greeted by a man standing behind the counter.
    I asked what size LCD TVs he sold.
    “Anything from a 10in up to 46in,” he said.
    I explained I was looking for a TV for my bedroom and wondered what size was best.
    “19in is a popular size for the bedroom,” he said, pointing to a Humax set.
    I said I would like something a bit bigger.
    He said he stocked 26in sets from JVC, Sharp and Samsung and pointed out that the Samsung set at £379 was “popular at the moment”. He said he could also get Panasonic TVs.
    All the TVs were turned off, bar a 40in Samsung set, which was showing the BBC HD channel. Typing into his computer, the man said: “There’s a Panasonic X10 at £499, there might be an S10, which will be slightly cheaper.”
    He switched on the 26in Samsung set, which was showing Freeview and I commented on the good picture quality.
    I asked for some information on any of the sets he had talked about, but he said he had no brochures but could print me out a PDF.
    Summary: The man was friendly, but didn’t seem to offer me any reason to buy. I would have preferred if all the sets were switched on.

    Score: 6 out of 10


    Drumming up business

    OUR washing machine recently gave up the ghost, so I headed to the Comet store on Tevillegate in search of a replacement. I started to browse the washer-dryers, when I was greeted by Mike, who asked if he could help.
    Pointing to Adam, Mike said he had someone knowledgeable who could help me.
    Adam joined me and I explained our washing machine had failed and that I was interested in a washer-dryer, but did not know much about their features or benefits.
    “The main benefit is that you get a dryer,” Adam joked. He asked what spin speed we had on the old machine and I said it was a 1,200 spin model.
    He explained that washer-dryers had two different load capacities, one for washing, and one for drying. He presented three models – an Indesit (WIDXL146) at £349·99, a Hotpoint (WDL520P) at £394·99 and a Bosch (WVD24520GB) at £579.
    He said a key benefit of the Bosch model was the LED display that showed how long a programme had left to run. The Hotpoint model, meanwhile, offered a bigger drum than the Indesit machine.
    Adam said the store could deliver and install a new product for £34·95, while removal of the defunct appliance would cost £8·95. He told me that I could have any of the three models delivered in two days’ time. He gave me a printout about the three models.
    Summary: Adam had a good style, however, he seemed unable to differentiate between the three products he presented, instead opting to give me a printout for me to decide which product best suited my needs.

    Score: 7 out of 10


    No US fridges here

    I CALLED in at Barkers Domestic Appliances on Teville Road to fi nd a fridge-freezer for our new apartment in central Worthing. Entering the store, I was greeted by a friendly man, who asked if he could help me.
    I explained that my partner was keen to buy an American-style product.
    “We don’t stock them at the moment, to be honest with you, as we’re only selling the budget stuff,” the man said. “That’s where the market is going, but I can get them.”
    I caught sight of some point-of-sale material that was promoting the Hotpoint Quadrio fridge-freezer. Pointing to the p-o-s, I asked him what this was.
    “That’s the Quadrio,” the man said, “the top is the fridge and the two drawers below are freezers, it’s 700mm in size.” He picked up a copy of the Hotpoint refrigeration brochure and pointed out that it was available in black and stainless steel.
    He told me that they were “always on back order”.
    I asked how much the Quadrio would cost. He said he would have to go and give someone a call to find out.
    After a few moments, he returned and told me that the Quadrio would cost £699·99, and that it would be delivered, free-of-charge, in two to three weeks. His company would also take away my old appliance. I thanked him for his help.
    Summary: The man was friendly, but failed to ask any questions which would have helped him best ascertain my needs. Using my answers, he would have been able to better serve me.

    Score: 3 out of 10


    S, V and W all in HD

    WALKING down Portland Road, I went into the Sony Centre, as I was keen on buying a new TV.
    Inside the store, two 37in TVs caught my eye – the KDL37S5500 and the KDL37V5500U, which were priced at £849·99 and £649·95. Pointof- sale materials indicated that both came with a three-year warranty.
    I then noticed some Freesat point-of-sale material and thought that. as well as a TV for the living room, I might consider a Freesat box for the bedroom.
    After four minutes browsing – I was the only customer – Jack approached me and asked if I needed any help. He asked me what screen size I’d like and I said a 37in. He told me that Sony had three 37in sets – the S, V and W series. He presented the two TVs I had previously been looking at.
    “The main difference between these,” Jack said, “is that the V series has a highresolution screen, which is a real benefit if you come to play with HD, especially on things like Blu-ray and PlayStation 3, which will be a lot crisper and sharper.”
    On the Freesat front, Jack told me that Freesat has two high-definition channels – the BBC HD Channel, while ITV shows HD content through the interactive red button service. I asked him how many channels there were on Freesat.
    “I think you get about 100 channels, but we’ve not had it that long,” said Jack.
    He pointed to a Sony set that was showing the BBC HD Channel and told me that the Humax Foxsat HD box would cost £159·99, although a recordable box was also available at £299·99.
    Summary: Jack seemed very knowledgeable. I have scored him down, however, for leaving me for nearly four minutes to browse in an empty shop. He did not attempt to close the sale and also got the number of Freesat channels wrong – there are more than 140.

    Score: 7 out of 10


    Got the Blu-ray blues

    MY HUSBAND had asked me to fi nd out more about Blu-ray for him, so I called in at the Currys.digital store on Montague Street.
    On entering the store, a member of staff greeted me and I made my way to the Blu-ray area of the store.
    I saw four members of staff, two of whom were serving customers.
    There were six Blu-ray players on display from LG, Panasonic, Samsung, Sharp and Sony.
    According to the point-of-sale material, the Panasonic model (DMP-BD35) would come with two free Blu-ray movies, as part of a special offer.
    I was interested in two of the models, the Panasonic one at £179·99 and the Sharp (BH-HP21H) at £244·66.
    After five minutes, with no sign of any approach from any of the sales assistants, I left the store.
    Summary: This visit started well and the store scored a point for its friendly greeting. Unfortunately, that was as good as it got and I left the store disappointed that I had been subsequently ignored.

    Score: 1 out of 10


    In the frame for a big zero

    WITH a big birthday coming up, I thought I’d pop into the Jessops store on Warwick Street to look at the present I was hoping to receive – a digital SLR.
    I entered the store and made my way to the digital SLR displays. I noticed a member of staff was serving a customer, while another customer was using a selfservice photo kiosk.
    Two other members of staff were chatting behind the counter.
    I was impressed with the Sony digital SLR display and I particularly liked the look of the A350, a 14 megapixel model, which was on sale at £439. The A700, a 12 megapixel model, was priced at £799.
    The price of the A350 included an 18-70mm lens, while the A700 was packaged with a 16-105mm lens.
    After five minutes of browsing, and with no sign of an approach, I left the store, thoroughly disappointed.
    Summary: In a recession, stores cannot afford to ignore customers. Is having a chat with a colleague more important than serving customers? There is only one possible answer in my opinion.

    Score: 0 out of 10


    Service not worth a bean

    MY WIFE has been nagging me for ages to get her a coffee maker, so I visited Debenhams on South Street to see what was available.
    I took the lift to the third floor, where the small domestic appliances were located. I was the only customer in the department, while the only member of staff was on the telephone over the far side of the department.
    I quickly noticed two models in particular, the Krups Nescafe Dolce Gusto (KP210040) priced at £88 and the Bosch Tassimo (TAS4011GB) on display at £98.
    I very much liked the cream colour of the Krups product.
    I picked up a Dolce Gusto leaflet, but after five minutes of browsing, and with no signs of any approach from the member of staff who was no longer on the telephone, I pressed the button to call the lift.
    Summary: I was the only customer in the small domestic appliances area, but still the member of staff failed to even notice me. Another example of staff ignoring customers. What can I say?

    Score: 0 out of 10


    Can’t find their way to a sale

    I WAS keen to buy a satnav for my new car, so I drove to the Currys store on the Lyons Farm Retail Park.
    On entering the store, four members of staff were chatting by the sales counter, so I made my way to the satnav display, which was right next to where they were standing. I was ignored.
    Among all the TomTom products on display, I found two models that I thought would fit the bill – the Go 530 at £249·99 and the Go 540 Live at £279·99.
    Posters around the satnav display were promoting a cashback deal that meant purchasers of the Go 540 Live, Go 740 Live and Go 940 Live, could claim back £10, £30 and £20 respectively.
    With no sign of any member of staff approaching me, and with just two other customers in the store, I reluctantly walked out, extremely disappointed.
    Summary: How can four members of staff fail to serve a customer who has chosen to strategically stand right next to them? The fact that I was ignored – with staff preferring to have a chit chat – speaks volumes.

    Score: 0 out of 10


    Summary

    MY team enjoyed its day in Worthing. While the sun was shining in the West Sussex resort, it was a shame that around half of the stores we visited, were far from shining examples of customer service.
    As I have written many times before in ERT, retailers, of whatever shape or size, can ill afford to ignore customers, something that Currys, Debenhams and Jessops would do well to reflect on. If the Currys store had not greeted our shopper, they, too, would have scored a zero.
    A special mention should go to the salesman at Roger Green Sound and Vision. He demonstrated the product and had the right balance of product knowledge and sales skills – a joy to witness in these tough times.
    Together with the man at Roger Green, staff at Lyles, the Sony Centre and Comet really seemed to enjoy selling.
    Barkers and Churchers did OK, but if they had asked questions to ascertain our shoppers’ needs, they would have been able to talk about the right kind of products, which would have resulted in their getting a higher score.
    Finally, congratulations to Roger Green Sound and Vision, Lyles, the Sony Centre and Comet. As you scored more than seven points, you will be automatically entered in this year’s ERT Industry Awards, which will take place in October.


    Top of the Town Independent

    Independents

    Winner
    Roger Green

    Commended
    Lyles

    Multiples

    Winner
    None

    Commended
    Comet

    Premier League

    No of Visits
    Total Points
    Average per call
    B&O 2 20 10
    Apple stores 3 25 8.3
    Shop@Panasonic 6 41 6.8
    Independents 48 308 6.4
    Sony Centres 16 97 6.1
    Supermarkets 4 22 5.5
    Richer Sounds 9 45 5
    Currys.digital 14 58 4.1
    Comet 15 47 3.1
    Department Stores 15 40 2.7
    Jessops 14 36 2.6
    Xtra Vision 1 2 2
    Currys 13 9 0.7
    Robert Dyas 1 0 0
    PC World 3 0 0